My 2¢

Bigotry in all of its many forms is not an honest difference of opinion. It is an obstacle to the progress of humanity. Whether it be based on race, religion, gender, gender identity, nationality or ethnicity, bigotry is one of our great problems. And to live by my own values I must stand against it.

If I live my values I might come into conflict with those whose values are different than mine. And I also value community and good will toward all. So I might feel an internal conflict if speaking up for what I believe in might damage a relationship or break the community. Two yoga principles will help me. They are ahimsa and satya, non-violence and truthfulness. These ideas are not unique to yoga, of course. They must be practically universal throughout history.

When non-violence to the community and being truthful on important matters are apparently in conflict, how do I decide my action? Some of the great commenters on the yoga sutras over the past two millennia have held that truthfulness is in support of non-violence. Truthfulness and non-violence are not separable and are truly not in conflict with each other. An ethical code with integrity could not include conflicting principles or values.

The intention is to live one’s principles with integrity. To be truthful while not thinking, speaking or acting in violence. Truth must never result in violence. “One should not speak the truth unkindly.”

So how do I do this? I can try to keep my statements in the affirmative. I have two younger brothers. I can talk politics with the older of the two. He and I can have a good-natured, candid debate. My younger brother I’m not so sure. I think a disagreement over politics would quickly become personal. The relationship would be put at risk. When I think that a disagreement might do harm but I feel compelled to speak, I can state my values in the affirmative, rather than criticize another’s values in the negative.

If I become engaged on the subject of the recent election, rather than debate or confront I could say, “I won’t say how I voted, the ballot is secret. But I will tell you how I decide my vote. I want human dignity for all; I want a nation that does not hold itself superior to others – a nation that recognizes one world; I want to live in a nation and a world where everyone is free from unfair discrimination and oppression; I want a country and a world where no one’s self-determination is restricted by law or by custom; I want there to be an honoring and a reverence for our home – the natural world; I want a nation where it is fully recognized that greed is destructive and is a violence upon others, where it is fully recognized that hoarding wealth and monopolizing natural resources is destructive and is in fact a violence upon others; I want my country to honor all spiritual traditions; I want a nation where taking care of our own is not controversial, where all of my countrymen have unfettered access to good healthcare, good education, good housing, good food and water and a good retirement. I vote for the candidate whose actions I think will best align with my values.”

Bigotry of any sort is by definition unreasonable. It is not based upon any observable fact. It is not based in truth. It is not open for debate. And it divides us and that is a violence. I cannot correct someone who holds a harmful and unreasoned position. I might be speaking truth, but it would likely only divide us further. If I am to help, if I am to live by my principles with integrity, I must keep non-violence uppermost in my mind while speaking the truth. I must speak truth kindly and be careful of how much truth can be constructively received in this moment. I can be careful not to press beyond a point where resentment and defensiveness replace listening.

Gandhi said, “The first principle of non-violent action is that of non-cooperation with everything humiliating.” I cannot – and should not – force my views on another. But I can bear non-violent witness to the truth. And I don’t have to cooperate with what is humiliating to myself or to others.



10 responses to “My 2¢

  1. I will speak out against bigotry and pushing some groups down to raise others up. today I called my senator to speak out against Trump’s appointment of Mr Bain. he should not hold a high office after he made clear his nationalist views. I am taking a stand and speaking out. I may not be able to stop these appointments but I can say I do not agree. If enough of us do that, it may affect those who make the laws.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. So important that we don’t lose sight of the bigger issues, our unity as a people and a world. I will speak up against bigotry and I believe everyone needs to. That isn’t something that can be accepted. And yet, we can do so with a non-harming intent.

    Liked by 1 person

    • It is the easy way through, isn’t it, to react and meet anger with anger. To stay engaged with it all and not get pulled away from the humane takes mindfulness and unwavering good will. This is hard work, and it is the work that must be done. As you say, Reena … So important that we don’t lose sight of the bigger issues. Political leaders won’t help with this. This has to come from the people. Peace

      Liked by 1 person

  3. Teacher, beautifully said. I will read and re-read this. It gives me more food for thought. Now, for what it’s worth, my $ .02. While this election is causing Americans to finally wake up I remain mystified that it has taken so long. All these years since 9/11 Americans have had their heads stuck in the sand. Meanwhile both neoliberal political parties dismantle our constitution, wreak terror with reckless wanton wars in other countries, cause 100,000s of deaths of children under 5 y.o., millions more deaths, costing billions of taxpayer dollars and military escalation/provocation with potential for WW3. Many have been blindsided by the corporate owned media, unwilling to look for the truth, do the hard work needed to change the terrifying course our country and its NATO allies have set us on. The greed and violence have been going on a long time and I agree….change comes when people awaken and show compassion for all beings on this planet.

    Liked by 1 person

    • We have to be careful to not allocate too much of our energy to worry and all. We need that energy for ourselves and for others in order to stay strong and think clearly about how to go forward. And identifying the problem is a first step. And always, we must not get caught up in our reactions so much that we are tempted to stray from our principles. Peace, my friend.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s